Orthopädische Gelenk-Klinik

Orthopädische Gelenk-Klinik

Alte Bundesstr. 58, 79194 Gundelfingen

Tel: (0761) 55 77 58 0


Termin anfragen

Prospective, randomized, multi-centered clinical trial assessing safety and efficacy of a synthetic cartilage implant versus first metatarsophalangeal arthrodesis in advanced hallux rigidus

TitelProspective, randomized, multi-centered clinical trial assessing safety and efficacy of a synthetic cartilage implant versus first metatarsophalangeal arthrodesis in advanced hallux rigidus
Publication TypeJournal Article
Year of Publication2016
AuthorsBaumhauer, JF, Singh, D, Glazebrook, M, Blundell, C, De Vries, G, Le, ILD, Nielsen, D, M Pedersen, E, Sakellariou, A, Solan, M, others,
JournalFoot & ankle international
SchlüsselwörterCartiva, hallux rigidus
Zusammenfassung Background:
Although a variety of great toe implants have been tried in an attempt to maintain toe motion, the majority have failed with loosening, malalignment/dislocation, implant fragmentation and bone loss. In these cases, salvage to arthrodesis is more complicated and results in shortening of the ray or requires structural bone graft to reestablish length. This prospective study compared the efficacy and safety of this small (8/10 mm) hydrogel implant to the gold standard of a great toe arthrodesis for advanced-stage hallux rigidus.
Methods: In this prospective, randomized non-inferiority study, patients from 12 centers in Canada and the United Kingdom were randomized (2:1) to a synthetic cartilage implant or first metatarsophalangeal (MTP) joint arthrodesis. VAS pain scale, validated outcome measures (Foot and Ankle Ability Measure [FAAM] sport scale), great toe active dorsiflexion motion, secondary procedures, radiographic assessment, and safety parameters were evaluated. Analysis was performed using intent-to-treat (ITT) and modified ITT (mITT) methodology. The primary endpoint for the study consisted of a single composite endpoint using the 3 primary study outcomes (pain, function, and safety). The individual subject’s outcome was considered a success if all of the following criteria were met: (1) improvement (decrease) from baseline in VAS pain of ≥30% at 12 months; (2) maintenance of function from baseline in FAAM sports subscore at 12 months; and (3) absence of major safety events at 2 years. The proportion of successes in each group was determined and 1-sided 95% confidence interval for the difference between treatment groups was calculated. Noninferiority of the implant to arthrodesis was considered statistically significant if the 1-sided 95% lower confidence interval was greater than the equivalence limit (<15%). A total of 236 patients were initially enrolled; 17 patients withdrew prior to randomization, 17 patients withdrew after randomization, and 22 were nonrandomized training patients, leaving 152 implant and 50 arthrodesis patients. Standard demographics and baseline outcomes were similar for both groups.
Conclusion: A prospective, randomized (2:1), controlled, noninferiority clinical trial was performed to compare the safety and efficacy of a small synthetic cartilage bone implant to first MTP arthrodesis in patients with advanced-stage hallux rigidus. This study showed equivalent pain relief and functional outcomes. The synthetic implant was an excellent alternative to arthrodesis in patients who wished to maintain first MTP motion. The percentage of secondary surgical procedures was similar between groups. Less than 10% of the implant group required revision to arthrodesis at 2 years.
Level of Evidence: Level I, prospective randomized study.
Full Text
Folgen Sie der Gelenk-Klinik auf Facebook oder Twitter

Wählen Sie ein Gelenk

Für eine medizinische Fragestellung - Coxarthrose, Arthrose, Gonarthrose, Sprungelenksarthrose, Hüftprothese, Hüftgelenks-TEP, Karpaltunnel-Syndrom, Facettengelenksarthrose etc klicken Sie auf ein Gelenk der orthopädischen Abbildung oben: Sie gelangen dann zu allen wichtigen Informationen Schulter, Sehnenverkalkung, Frozen Shoulder, Auskugelungen, Schultergelenks-Arthrose, Omarthrose, Schleimbeutel, Rotatorenmanschette Taube Hände, Karpaltunnelsyndrom, Medianus Neurolyse minimalinvasiv durchführen Huefte, Coxarthrose, Cox-Arthrose, Hueft-TEP, künstliches Hüftgelenk, Hüftprothese, Hüftschmerzen, Hüftnekrose, Ellenbogen-Gelenk Handgelenk: taube Hände und das Karpaltunnelsyndrom, Medianus Neurolyse minimalinvasiv durchführen knie Haglundferse, Fersensporn, Morton Neurom, Metatarsalgie,  Fuss, Zehen, Hallux Valgus, Hallux Rigidus, Schiefe Zehen, Hammerzehe, Krallenzehe, Korrektur Sprunggelenk, Sprunggelenksprothese, Knöchel, Fussgelenk, Sprunggelenk-Arthrose, Sprunggelenk-Prothese, Sprungelenksarthroskopie, Knorpeltransplantation, Chondrozytentransplantation Wirbelsäule, Bandscheibe, Lendenwirbelsäule, Halswirbelsäule, Bandscheibenvorfall, Rückenschmerzen

MVZ Gelenk-Klinik

Informationen zu Untersuchung und stationärem Aufenthalt in der orthopädischen Gelenk Klinik

MVZ Gelenk-Klinik
EndoProthetikZentrum (EPZ) und Zentrum für Sprung- und Fußgelenk (ZFS)


  • Orthopädie
  • Arthrosetherapie
  • Unfallchirurgie
  • Endoprothesen
  • Neurochirurgie
  • Rehabilitative Medizin

Tel: (0761) 55 77 58 0


Virtueller Rundgang

360° Virtueller Rundgang: Ansicht der Ambulanz